Skip to main content

Resource Graph

OpenTF builds a dependency graph from the OpenTF configurations, and walks this graph to generate plans, refresh state, and more. This page documents the details of what are contained in this graph, what types of nodes there are, and how the edges of the graph are determined.

~> Advanced Topic! This page covers technical details of OpenTF. You don't need to understand these details to effectively use OpenTF. The details are documented here for those who wish to learn about them without having to go spelunking through the source code.

For some background on graph theory, and a summary of how OpenTF applies it, see the HashiCorp 2016 presentation Applying Graph Theory to Infrastructure as Code. This presentation also covers some similar ideas to the following guide.

Graph Nodes​

There are only a handful of node types that can exist within the graph. We'll cover these first before explaining how they're determined and built:

  • Resource Node - Represents a single resource. If you have the count metaparameter set, then there will be one resource node for each count. The configuration, diff, state, etc. of the resource under change is attached to this node.

  • Provider Configuration Node - Represents the time to fully configure a provider. This is when the provider configuration block is given to a provider, such as AWS security credentials.

  • Resource Meta-Node - Represents a group of resources, but does not represent any action on its own. This is done for convenience on dependencies and making a prettier graph. This node is only present for resources that have a count parameter greater than 1.

When visualizing a configuration with opentf graph, you can see all of these nodes present.

Building the Graph​

Building the graph is done in a series of sequential steps:

  1. Resources nodes are added based on the configuration. If a diff (plan) or state is present, that meta-data is attached to each resource node.

  2. Resources are mapped to provisioners if they have any defined. This must be done after all resource nodes are created so resources with the same provisioner type can share the provisioner implementation.

  3. Explicit dependencies from the depends_on meta-parameter are used to create edges between resources.

  4. If a state is present, any "orphan" resources are added to the graph. Orphan resources are any resources that are no longer present in the configuration but are present in the state file. Orphans never have any configuration associated with them, since the state file does not store configuration.

  5. Resources are mapped to providers. Provider configuration nodes are created for these providers, and edges are created such that the resources depend on their respective provider being configured.

  6. Interpolations are parsed in resource and provider configurations to determine dependencies. References to resource attributes are turned into dependencies from the resource with the interpolation to the resource being referenced.

  7. Create a root node. The root node points to all resources and is created so there is a single root to the dependency graph. When traversing the graph, the root node is ignored.

  8. If a diff is present, traverse all resource nodes and find resources that are being destroyed. These resource nodes are split into two: one node that destroys the resource and another that creates the resource (if it is being recreated). The reason the nodes must be split is because the destroy order is often different from the create order, and so they can't be represented by a single graph node.

  9. Validate the graph has no cycles and has a single root.

Walking the Graph​

To walk the graph, a standard depth-first traversal is done. Graph walking is done in parallel: a node is walked as soon as all of its dependencies are walked.

The amount of parallelism is limited using a semaphore to prevent too many concurrent operations from overwhelming the resources of the machine running OpenTF. By default, up to 10 nodes in the graph will be processed concurrently. This number can be set using the -parallelism flag on the plan, apply, and destroy commands.

Setting -parallelism is considered an advanced operation and should not be necessary for normal usage of OpenTF. It may be helpful in certain special use cases or to help debug OpenTF issues.

Note that some providers (AWS, for example), handle API rate limiting issues at a lower level by implementing graceful backoff/retry in their respective API clients. For this reason, OpenTF does not use this parallelism feature to address API rate limits directly.